Buying gold comes down to three channels: a local coin shop, an online bullion dealer, or the United States Mint itself. Each charges a different premium over the spot price, and that gap is where first-time buyers quietly lose money. Here is how the channels compare and which products resell without a fight.
This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Who Actually Needs Physical Gold
Physical gold is investment-grade metal, purity-stamped and sold by weight in troy ounces, grams, or kilograms. Two families dominate. Sovereign coins are struck by government mints, including the American Eagle and the Canadian Maple Leaf. Bars come from refiners accredited by the London Bullion Market Association, the trade body behind the Good Delivery standard, among them PAMP Suisse and Valcambi. Jewelry is a third category, priced on fabrication rather than raw metal.
Buyers are specific: people hedging fiat currency, retirement savers using self-directed IRAs, and families moving wealth down a generation. Mining supply grows slowly, so supply and demand does the price work, and central banks have been net buyers for years. The United States Mint, the federal body that strikes American bullion coins, publishes fineness basics, and the IRS sets the .995 minimum governing most retirement accounts. Tax treatment varies by state, so talk to a licensed advisor first.
Buying Criteria: What Separates a Fair Gold Deal From a Bad One
Premium over spot. The spot price of gold is the live wholesale quote for one troy ounce in U.S. dollars. Premium is what a dealer adds for minting, distribution, and margin. Quotes move all day, so pull a live figure and compare sellers on the same afternoon. Any premium printed in a guide, including this one, is stale before you read it.
Purity and fineness. Bars and most sovereign coins are stamped .999 or .9999, and reputable bars arrive sealed in tamper-evident assay cards with matching serial numbers. Cut the seal and you cut the resale value. The American Eagle is the exception at .9167, alloyed with copper and silver for durability, yet it still holds one full troy ounce of fine metal.
Size and liquidity. One-ounce coins trade fastest and carry the tightest bid-ask spreads. Fractional 1/10 and 1/4 ounce pieces cost more per ounce but let you liquidate in slices. A kilogram bar gives the lowest cost per ounce and sells only whole.
Retirement eligibility. The IRS permits specific bullion inside a self-directed IRA: American Eagle, American Buffalo, Canadian Maple Leaf, Austrian Philharmonic, and approved-refiner bars at .995 or better. Collectible pieces are excluded, so a rare-coin retirement pitch deserves a hard no.
Storage and insurance. A bolted fireproof safe handles modest holdings; larger positions belong in a bank box or an insured depository. Standard homeowner policies apply a low sub-limit to coins, so ask about a scheduled rider first.
How to Price a Purchase Before You Order
- Pull the live spot quote per troy ounce from a feed you trust.
- Subtract it from each listed price to get the real premium in dollars.
- Add shipping and card surcharges, then ask each seller for its buyback number.
Red Flags When Shopping for Gold
Numismatic pricing sold as bullion pricing. A collectible coin is priced on rarity and condition; a one-ounce American Eagle is priced on spot plus a premium. Margins on the first are far richer, so say which you want before anyone opens a case.
Television and mailer promotions. Free-metals kits and proof-set offers routinely carry markups well above what a mainstream bullion dealer charges.
Private sales you cannot verify. Tungsten-core fakes and plated blanks circulate constantly, and the Professional Numismatists Guild, the dealer accreditation body, tells buyers to stay with established sellers. Without a precision scale, calipers, and an intact assay card, remote verification is guesswork.
Ignoring the buyback number. Every dealer quotes two prices, the sell and the buyback. A wide gap means a quick exit costs real money.
Buying Gold Locally: Shop by Shop
Local buying puts metal in your hand the same day, with no shipping exposure and a chance to inspect the assay card before you pay. Counter premiums usually sit above what online sellers post.
Independent Coin Shops
Independent dealers are the most common counter you can walk up to, and most keep Eagles, Maple Leafs, and fractional pieces in the case. Find them through the Professional Numismatists Guild directory or a local business directory search for your metro. Ask the buyback spread today. A shop that also quotes platinum and palladium is running a real trading desk, not a display case.
Banks and Credit Unions
Only a handful of U.S. banks sell bullion over the counter, and almost none hold it in the branch. Most special-order through a distributor, though a few international banks operating stateside carry Philharmonics. Call first, always.
Pawn Shops and Antique Dealers
Pawn shops sometimes have coins and small bars, but pricing targets impulse buyers and authentication is inconsistent. Estate sales carry the same problem collectible stamps do, where grading drives price more than material content.
Buying Gold Online: Dealer Comparison
Online bullion dealers post the lowest premiums because they carry no retail counter. Reputable ones ship insured and signature-required, which matters more than it sounds: somebody has to be home to sign.
| Dealer | Best for | Worth knowing |
|---|---|---|
| APMEX | Widest catalog | Coins, bars, historic pieces, active buyback program |
| JM Bullion | Sealed mint packaging | Free insured shipping above a stated order minimum; IRA products via approved custodians |
| SD Bullion | Low premiums | Bars from one gram to one kilogram; check and wire beat card checkout |
| Kitco | Price data plus retail | Widely watched spot feed; allocated storage available |
| BGASC | Fast shipping | Live charts beside each listing; competitive on standard Eagles |
| U.S. Mint | Guaranteed authenticity | Proof and uncirculated Eagles and Buffalos direct, higher premiums |
Marketplaces are the exception. Amazon restricts coins and bullion to approved sellers, so selection is thin and authentication is not the platform’s job. eBay works if you stay with established dealers and read feedback volume rather than percentage alone. The U.S. Gold Bureau ships a free investor kit, and USAGold.com publishes allocation notes. Want a second metal at a lower entry price? Our silver coins guide covers many of the same sellers.
What People Are Saying About Buying Bullion
Dealer reputation is easier to verify than product quality, since the coins themselves are commodities. On Trustpilot, JM Bullion buyers mostly describe quick, discreet, well-packed shipments. SD Bullion reviewers mention the same packaging consistency, and APMEX draws praise on Trustpilot and Reddit for its educational material.
Complaints cluster in two places. Signature-required delivery is the loudest theme: reviewers describe missed attempts and a carrier notice instead of the package. The second is shipping delay during price spikes, when order volume outruns the warehouse. Buyers in r/Gold and r/Silverbugs raise both regularly, along with light handling scratches on bars and rounds, cosmetic on bullion but irritating if you expected flawless surfaces. So buy sealed assay-card product if surface condition matters, and clear your calendar for delivery day.
Best Gold Products to Buy Right Now
Picks are chosen for liquidity, verifiable purity, and resale demand, not collector appeal. Buy from an established dealer rather than a general marketplace, because marketplaces do not authenticate bullion.
Best overall: American Gold Eagle 1 oz Coin. The most liquid coin in the U.S. resale market, federally backed and IRA-eligible under the statutory exception. Any dealer in the country will quote a buyback on it. Check current pricing at JM Bullion.
Best purity: Canadian Maple Leaf 1 oz Coin. Struck at .9999 by the Royal Canadian Mint, with a radial-line field and a micro-engraved security mark. Usually a slightly lower premium than the Eagle. Browse the APMEX catalog.
Best for retirement accounts: American Buffalo 1 oz Coin. The first .9999 fine piece from the United States Mint, carrying the Buffalo Nickel design. IRA-eligible, and typically priced above the Eagle. Order direct from the Mint.
Best bar: PAMP Suisse 1 oz Bar. Swiss-refined, .9999 fine, sealed in a CertiPAMP assay card with serial number and hologram. Bars carry lower premiums than sovereign coins, which is the whole point. See bar pricing at SD Bullion.
Best small entry: Fractional 1/10 oz Sovereign Coin. A 1/10 ounce Eagle or Britannia is the realistic first purchase for most households. Premium per ounce is the highest of any format, so treat it as a starting point. Compare fractional listings at BGASC.
Gold Questions, Answered
How much is one ounce worth right now?
The gold price changes every few seconds during market hours, so read a live feed rather than a figure printed on a page. Spot is the wholesale quote for pure metal, priced per troy ounce, which is 31.10 grams and not the 28.35-gram kitchen ounce. Most dealers lock your price at checkout and hold it briefly while payment clears.
Does the IRS know when you buy gold?
Ordinary purchases are not routinely reported. Cash payments above $10,000 trigger a dealer filing, and certain bulk sales back to a dealer are reported on Form 1099-B. The IRS treats physical bullion as a collectible when sold, which carries a higher maximum long-term rate, so keep every invoice.
What does the spread between the two quoted prices mean?
The spread is the gap between what a dealer sells a product for and what the same dealer pays to buy it back. It is the true cost of a round trip. Spreads run narrowest on common one-ounce coins and widest on odd sizes, proof sets, and privately branded rounds, worth knowing before you sell gold back.
Is a precious metals IRA worth the extra cost?
It adds a custodian fee, a depository fee, and a shorter product list, in exchange for tax-deferred treatment. Home storage of retirement-account metal is not permitted, so anyone marketing a home-storage IRA is describing something the IRS does not allow.
Start with the live spot quote, then price the same one-ounce coin at one local shop and two online dealers on a single afternoon; the lowest all-in total, shipping included, wins. Buy fractional first if the full-ounce number feels heavy. Once physical gold is in place, savings bonds round out the same corner of a portfolio.
Editorial Review and Verification
In September 2026, our editorial team re-verified dealer availability, shipping terms, and product picks, with reference to the United States Mint, the World Gold Council, the London Bullion Market Association, and IRS rules on precious metals in retirement accounts. Premiums and spot quotes move daily, so confirm live pricing before ordering. This page is informational, not individualized financial or tax advice.