Ricotta cheese is the tub you only miss when a recipe calls for it and the fridge comes up empty. Lasagna night, stuffed shells, cannoli filling: the style you pick changes the result more than most shoppers expect. Knowing where to buy it, which grade suits your dish, and which lookalikes to skip saves a second trip.
This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Who Actually Needs Ricotta Cheese
Ricotta is a fresh Italian whey cheese made by recooking the leftover whey from mozzarella or provolone production, which is what the name means: recooked. Heat and acid coagulate the remaining casein into soft, creamy white curds with a slightly sweet finish. It began as a thrifty byproduct of cheesemaking. Most American tubs now start from milk instead of whey alone, which lifts yield and is worth spotting on a label.
Who buys it? Cooks building baked pasta, ravioli, manicotti, and pizza; bakers filling pastry shells; and anyone who wants a mild, high-protein spread for toast with fresh herbs. Ounce for ounce it carries less sodium than aged types like parmesan or cheddar, which explains its culinary range from savory trays to dessert. The Wikipedia entry on ricotta covers the Sicily and Sardinia backstory.
Buying Criteria: What Separates Good Ricotta From Bad
A good tub has a short ingredient list, a curd that holds its shape on a spoon, and a fat grade matched to the dish. Five things to check.
Whole milk versus part skim. Whole milk ricotta is the richer, creamier option and the one most classic recipes assume. The leaner grade bakes firmer, so a tray slices cleanly. The grade is printed on the label, so read it rather than judging richness by the lid color. Nonfat turns chalky and weeps water.
Ingredient list. A clean label reads milk, whey, vinegar or citric acid, and salt. Gums such as xanthan, locust bean, and carrageenan get added because fresh cheese has a short shelf life. They also mute flavor and can set gummy once baked.
Curd style. Supermarket tubs are smooth and spoonable. Artisan producers press hand-dipped baskets with an irregular, fluffy curd that holds up on crostini. If a recipe says fresh or basket style, that is the one.
Milk source. Nearly every American tub is cow’s milk. Sheep milk versions, sold as ricotta di pecora, run tangier and firmer. Water buffalo is richest and rare stateside. Both live at full-service counters.
Package size. Grocery tubs run 15 ounces, enough for one 9-by-13 lasagna. Club tubs hit 3 pounds, which pays off only when cooking for a crowd, since this is perishable once opened.
| Style | Best for | Texture |
|---|---|---|
| Whole milk | Cannoli, cheesecake, spreads | Creamy, wettest |
| Part skim | Lasagna, stuffed shells | Firmer, less watery |
| Hand-dipped basket | Crostini, tomato salad | Fluffy, dense curd |
Red Flags When Shopping for Ricotta
The costliest mistake is paying near-name-brand money for a tub that hedges its name on the front of the package.
Anything labeled “style” or “blend.” A hedged name usually signals milk powder and stabilizers cut in to hit a price point. The curd feels rubbery and bakes flat.
Ultra-pasteurization plus heavy stabilizers. A long date is convenient, but high temperature processing strips the sweet cream note that makes fresh ricotta worth buying.
Bulging lids, standing liquid, or a date at the edge. A domed lid means fermentation started, and pooled whey past a thin surface film means the curd is breaking down. This is perishable, not an aged wheel, so check the printed use-by at warehouse clubs where specialty sizes turn slowly.
Previously frozen tubs. Freezing bursts the curd and it thaws grainy. Fine buried in baked ziti, useless raw. Store it at the back of the refrigerator, not the door, and never leave it at room temperature while you assemble.
Buying Ricotta Cheese Locally: Store by Store
Walmart
Walmart, the largest grocery seller in the United States, carries the broadest lineup at the lowest prices: Great Value, Galbani, Frigo, Polly-O, and Sorrento, in the refrigerated dairy aisle beside the cream cheese. Check the Walmart selection page first if you want a specific brand, since neighborhood-format stores carry a thinner mix.
Target
Target keeps Market Pantry plus a national label, the fastest stop when you need one 15-ounce tub. The Market Pantry listing confirms local stock.
Kroger, Publix, and Regional Chains
Kroger, Publix, Safeway, Albertsons, H-E-B, and Meijer each stock a store label alongside Galbani and Polly-O. Publix in the Southeast and Wegmans in the Northeast run the widest premium selection, including imported sheep milk tubs at the deli.
Whole Foods, Trader Joe’s, Sprouts, and the Clubs
Whole Foods Market shelves BelGioioso, Calabro, and Organic Valley in the specialty cheese case, not the main dairy aisle, which is where most shoppers give up looking. Trader Joe’s rotates a house tub and an organic one. Sprouts leans to smaller producers. Costco and Sam’s Club sell 3-pound Galbani or Precious tubs at a sharply lower per-ounce price.
Italian Delis and Specialty Markets
Neighborhood Italian delis are where hand-dipped baskets show up, often made that morning. Call ahead, since small batches sell out by early afternoon on weekends, and ask whether they carry ricotta di pecora or a true water buffalo tub. Timing note: before Christmas and Easter, the lasagna rush clears the cold case by mid-morning.
Buying Ricotta Online: Retailer Comparison
Online, only cold-chain grocery works: Amazon Fresh, Instacart, Shipt, Walmart.com, Target.com, and specialty shippers that pack with ice.
Amazon Fresh and Whole Foods Market on Amazon
Where delivery reaches you, same-day grocery on Amazon #ad covers BelGioioso, Galbani, Polly-O, and 365 by Whole Foods Market in refrigerated delivery. Shelf-stable pouches sold as ambient groceries on the main site are a different product, so stay inside the Fresh or Whole Foods storefronts.
Instacart, Shipt, and Store Pickup
Instacart pulls from Kroger, Publix, Costco, Wegmans, and Sprouts. Shipt covers Target, H-E-B, and Meijer. Delivery windows vary by market, so take the earliest slot and ask the shopper to grab the latest date on the lid. Walmart.com and Target.com also do same-day pickup, which keeps the tub coldest.
iGourmet and Direct From the Producer
For imported and specialty styles, iGourmet’s selection ships perishables in insulated packaging, and Antonelli’s Cheese Shop in Austin ships nationally. Calabro moves mostly through East Coast grocers and Italian markets. Order Monday through Wednesday so nothing sits in a warehouse over a weekend.
How Much Should You Pay for Ricotta
As of July 2026, a 15-ounce supermarket tub runs roughly $4 to $6, and a hand-dipped artisan basket lands closer to $8 to $12. Club packs cost the least per ounce by a wide margin.
| Tier | Typical price | What changes |
|---|---|---|
| Store brand | $3 to $5 per 15 oz | Often gum-stabilized, fine for baking |
| National brand | $4 to $6 per 15 oz | Cleaner labels, consistent curd |
| Artisan basket | $8 to $12 | Hand-dipped, no gums, best served raw |
Here is where paying more is wasted: any dish where it ends up under sauce. In a heavily sauced lasagna, a $10 basket tastes like a $5 tub out of the oven. Spend the premium on crostini, cannoli, or a spoonful over tomatoes. You can also make ricotta at home by heating fresh milk with citric acid or vinegar just short of a boil, then straining the curds through cheesecloth. Homemade ricotta cheese wins on freshness, not cost.
Best Ricotta Right Now
These five picks come from comparing labels, fat grades, and stocking breadth across the retailers above.
Best overall: BelGioioso Whole Milk Ricotta. Wisconsin-made from fresh milk and vinegar, no gums, with a sweet curd that bakes clean. Around $5 to $7. Check BelGioioso on Amazon #ad.
Best budget: Polly-O Original. The classic Italian American supermarket tub, bought from Kraft Heinz by BelGioioso in 2018, still widely stocked and dependable for a weeknight tray. Around $4 to $6. Find Polly-O on Amazon #ad.
Best artisan: Calabro Hand-Dipped. A Connecticut cheesemaker working in small batches, with a pillowy curd best eaten with olive oil, sea salt, and grilled bread. Around $8 to $12. Shop Calabro on Amazon #ad.
Best organic: Organic Valley. The farmer-owned cooperative’s organic tubs turn up in Whole Foods Market and Sprouts, with a short ingredient panel and a tangier finish. Around $6 to $8. See Organic Valley on Amazon #ad.
Best for baking: Galbani Part-Skim. Drier straight from the tub, so less liquid pools in a baked tray. Made by Lactalis, stocked almost everywhere. Around $4 to $6. Find Galbani on Amazon #ad.
Start with the label: full-fat for anything raw or sweet, the leaner grade for anything baked, four ingredients either way. If your store stocks only gum-thickened tubs, order ricotta cheese through Amazon Fresh or Instacart from a chain carrying BelGioioso or Calabro, or drive to an Italian deli on a Saturday morning. Pairing notes from our other guides: build a tray with fresh pasta sheets, finish cannoli with mascarpone, bake it into a cheesecake, and keep cheesecloth handy to drain a tub that arrives wet.
Ricotta Questions, Answered
Is ricotta cheese the same as cottage cheese?
No. Cottage cheese is a drained, curdled milk product with large, distinct curds and a salty tang. Ricotta starts from whey, so the curd is finer, sweeter, and smoother. It also releases far more liquid in a baked tray, so swapping one for the other rarely works without draining first.
Should I buy whole milk or part skim?
Match it to the dish. Whole milk is creamier and belongs in sweet fillings and anything spread on bread. The leaner grade is drier, so it holds a clean slice. Pick by recipe, not calorie count.
Why does my stomach hurt after eating ricotta cheese?
Because it is a fresh cheese, it holds far more lactose than aged wheels like parmesan, where months of aging consume most of the sugar. Portion size compounds it: a lasagna layer spreads one tub across eight servings, while a bowl with honey is a much larger dairy load.
Is ricotta salata the same thing?
No. Ricotta salata is the pressed, salted, aged version, firm enough for grating over pasta or shaving onto a tomato salad. In use it sits closer to queso fresco or feta than to the soft tub in the cold case.
Are store-brand tubs worth buying?
Often, yes. Great Value, Market Pantry, Kroger’s private label, and 365 by Whole Foods Market all turn out usable tubs at a real discount. Flip it over first: gum-stabilized store brands bake into a gummier set than a clean-label brand.
Editorial Note
In July 2026, our editorial team re-verified prices, retailer availability, and the product picks in this guide. Ranges reflect national grocery listings checked that month and shift with region and store format. No medical professional reviewed this page.